diff --git a/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderApprove.php b/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderApprove.php
index a1600cf..4baf8e9 100644
--- a/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderApprove.php
+++ b/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderApprove.php
@@ -32,9 +32,9 @@ class UserInfoUpdateOrderApprove extends Members
     public function getMemberParams(): array
     {
         return [
-            'zip_code' => $this->customer->zipCode,
-            'address' => $this->customer->address,
-            'phone_no' => $this->customer->phoneNumber,
+            'zip_code' => $this->app->zipCodeAfter,
+            'address' => $this->app->addressAfter,
+            'phone_no' => $this->app->phoneNoAfter,
             'memo' => $this->app->memo,
         ];
     }
diff --git a/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderNotice.php b/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderNotice.php
index 4cbad16..0386fa8 100644
--- a/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderNotice.php
+++ b/app/Email/Members/UserInfoUpdateOrderNotice.php
@@ -31,9 +31,9 @@ class UserInfoUpdateOrderNotice extends Members
     public function getMemberParams(): array
     {
         return [
-            'zip_code' => $this->customer->zipCode,
-            'address' => $this->customer->address,
-            'phone_no' => $this->customer->phoneNumber,
+            'zip_code' => $this->app->zipCodeAfterpCode,
+            'address' => $this->app->addressAfter,
+            'phone_no' => $this->app->phoneNoAfter,
             'memo' => $this->app->memo,
         ];
     }